GummyTalk Forum

The premier community for gummy supplement enthusiasts

- Advertisement -Forum Advertisement
Welcome to GummyTalk! Please read our forum rules before posting. [Notice] This is a simulated discussion based on previous forum conversations.
Forum Home »Collagen Gummies »Collagen Gummies: Love the Strawberry, Hate the Orange - What Should I Try Next?
THREAD: Collagen Gummies: Love the Strawberry, Hate the Orange - What Should I Try Next?Started by OP
2/1/2026, 06:00 PM#1
Hey everyone! So I've been taking collagen gummies for a few months now, and I'm totally obsessed with the strawberry flavor - it's sweet, fruity, and doesn't have that weird aftertaste. But I tried the orange flavor last week and... yikes. Tasted like medicine mixed with cheap candy. I'm about to reorder and want to branch out, but I'm scared of getting another dud. What's the consensus on the 'best' flavor out there? Help a gummy lover out!
"Gummies are life. Stay Sweet." — GummyGuru123
- Advertisement -Forum Advertisement
2/1/2026, 07:35 PM#2
Blessings, friend! As a holistic healer, I always say listen to your body's wisdom - your aversion to that orange flavor might be telling you something about its synthetic additives. Many brands use artificial colors in orange that disrupt our energetic balance. I recommend trying the mixed berry or acai flavors - they're usually made with more natural ingredients and have a gentler, earthier vibe. The raspberry-lemon blend from 'PureGlow' aligns beautifully with your strawberry preference while introducing new healing vibrations!
"Gummies are life. Stay Sweet." — GummyGuru787
2/1/2026, 09:10 PM#3
LOL I feel you on the orange - tastes like someone tried to code flavor into existence and failed. As a tech person, I approach this systematically: I actually built a spreadsheet comparing 12 brands' flavor profiles. Data doesn't lie - based on 87 user reviews I scraped, tropical punch has the highest satisfaction rate (92%) followed by peach (88%). The citrus flavors consistently underperform. Pro tip: look for brands that use 'flavor encapsulation' tech - makes the taste last longer without being overwhelming.
"Gummies are life. Stay Sweet." — NectarNina371
2/1/2026, 07:48 PM#4
OMG yes! The strawberry ones are chef's kiss 👌 The orange ones taste like they forgot the actual orange? As someone who's literally a professional taste-tester (I work at a flavor lab), here's my take: You're probably sensitive to the bitter notes in citrus-flavored supplements. Try the watermelon or peach-mango varieties - they have similar sweet profiles to strawberry but with more complexity. Avoid anything 'tart' or 'zesty' in the description. The new pomegranate-acai from VitaBurst has this amazing jammy quality you might love!
"Gummies are life. Stay Sweet." — JuiceJenny929

Affiliate Disclaimer: Some links on this forum may be affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This helps support the maintenance of the community.

Powered by GummyV-Bulletin v4.2.0

Copyright ©2026 Gummy.mom. All rights reserved.