DIY gummy vitamins – how do I keep them from turning into jelly bricks?

OP: GummyGuruGina (not in list)August 4, 2026
O
OP: GummyGuruGina (not in list)
Aug 4, 2026, 02:00 PM

So I tried making my own multivitamin gummies using gelatin and a bunch of vitamin powders (C, B12, D3). I followed a recipe I saw online: 1/2 cup cold water, 2 tbsp gelatin, 1/4 cup honey, and 1/4 tsp of each powder. Heated it all up, poured into silicone molds, and put in fridge. But they came out super hard – like chewy candy but not gummy. What am I doing wrong? Also, some of the powder didn't dissolve and left gritty bits. Any tips?

E
EarthElias661
Aug 4, 2026, 03:55 PM

Hey! Keto guy here, so I'm all about homemade stuff. First off, if you want soft gummies, you need to balance gelatin and liquid. Too much gelatin = rubbery. Try using less, like 1.5 tbsp per 1/2 cup liquid, and maybe add a bit of citric acid or lemon juice – that helps soften. Also, dissolve the vitamin powders in a small amount of warm water first, then mix into the gelatin mixture. And never boil – just heat gently. That should help with the grittiness. Keep the heat low! My first batch was a disaster too, so keep experimenting.

V
VitalVince
Aug 4, 2026, 03:02 PM

Honestly, I wonder if it's safe to DIY gummies with vitamin powders. You could easily get the dosage wrong and end up with megadoses. Not to mention, the heat might destroy some vitamins. My kids take store-bought ones because they're regulated. But if you're set on it, maybe use agar instead of gelatin? Agar sets firmer but can be more jiggly if you use less. Also, I add a little oil to keep them from sticking. But yeah, careful with the dosage!

N
NectarNina773
Aug 4, 2026, 08:30 PM

Tech girl here – I just got a 3D printed mold and an immersion circulator for precise temp control. I read that you should bloom the gelatin in cold water first for 5 mins, then heat to 140°F max. And use a digital scale to measure powders so it's consistent. Also, if you want them softer, add more liquid the next time, like 3/4 cup total. My first batch was like little erasers, but after tweaking, they're perfect. Oh, and I use a whisk to make sure everything's dissolved, then strain through a fine mesh before pouring. Might sound OCD but it works!